agree it could have been worded differently, but still a stupid decision.

Anyway, Calderdale Council... They're a bit rubbish hey?

Possibly, but at least it shows the feelings attached to the decision.

Looks like Fax are trying to work with Siddal and organise a good days rugby only to be scuppered by council halfwits.

If it's a stewarding thing then what about asking Siddal to assist on this front?

Usual rubbish from yourself. Why is it embarrassing? The Council again show how useless they are and poor at organizing things. The club have said so and maybe it will get the Council thinking. How come its OK to have 3 or 4 games at one venue in Cardiff, Warrington, Headingley having 10s of thousands of people in attendance but not 2 games which are likely to struggle to reach 1500? There is no Health & Safety issue and why cant the Council communicate properly with the clubs before making such decisions based on nonsense?

As for shameful behaviour the soccer lot are way in front! If certain people involved at the Soccer club had done jobs properly and built the upgrades with Quality then the Council would not need to finish things off. The Shameful actions of the Soccer club in deliberately getting kicked out of a cup. The Shameful behaviour of the Soccer fans by claiming Fax do not pay rent etc and spreading slanderous rumours?

I'm sure it's not so much the council, the man who made the call was Gary Byrne with the help of the two groundsmen.

loverugbyleague.com/news_5056-hu ... ition.html leeds council love rugby league too....

loverugbyleague.com/news_5056-hu ... ition.html leeds council love rugby league too....

So the clubs must show their gratitude at all times by wringing caps, touching forelocks and capitulating on every issue?

The council have invested a lot of public money in The Shay and, as a council tax payer, I would like to see a return on that investment by maximisation of revenue streams. They are hardly doing that in this instance.

agreed

your link dont work, but ive already posted it about hunslet on this post

Ah right - so reading your acidic comments all you're bothered about is putting the boot into the Rugby club. No mention from you of the actual decision - just a diatribe of anti-Halifax RLFC rhetoric.

Don't reply by telling us how you're a fan of the rugby too - it"s a load of crap.

You're pathetic. You should actually apply to work for the Council - you're well matched.

What a good idea that would stick two fingers up to those at the Coumcil wouldn't it!
Thing is as its a Local Authority and as such this is a PUBLIC service I want to know WHO made this decision, come on stand up by your own ruling I dare you stop hiding behind H&S if it is that?

Just spotted this if so they work for the Council in a Council owned facility and I have got to ask who is their boss?
Who runs the Shay now people wise as I get confused?
Come on why is the management letting two groundsmen run a whole facility? This is a COMMUNITY STADIUM not just a sports pitch.
Is this more about spitting their dummies out of the pram and getting their own back by being bl^^dy minded?
DISGRACE this.

Let them enjoy that rare moment of success against us they will need a long memory hopefully this season too!

Give this man a big stick for his usual stirrings.

Unbelieveable rubbish this even having a pop at poor old Siddal!

Oh and regards the East Stand that was done as a result of massive public pressure and luckily the CE had it as one of his targets too!

Stadium management means just that you can make management decisions including what you charge.

I see the romance of the challenge cup is dead & buried even at the 3rd round stage. Not that I'm a supporter of the Siddal club, although I do have a son who plays for their under 16's team currently, but why has nobody considered their side of things.
It's Siddal's home tie, so make Widnes come & play at Chevinedge. The facilities there are as good as let's say what Oldham or Swinton or South Wales have offered over the past few seasons. I hear that Widnes were been a little bit awkward from the onset, insisting on playing at their home stadium and giving a one-off payment to Siddal. Also, I'm not sure how many junior fixtures they have scheduled in for the challenge cup day, but would they wish to cancel those fixtures to maximise their support, and the week after, the under 16's are playing in the Yorkshire cup final versus Hunslet boys, I'm sure they need to play next weekend to prepare for their big day out too.
Good old professional rugby league, another joke story.

Surely considering the amount of tremendous work done by the Siddal club on behalf of the community ( for it is the amatuer clubs that do the ' real ' community work , giving the young people of the town a focus generally unavailable these days ) , it is only reasonable that the council do all they can to reward the Siddal club with as good a day as they can

Part of that reward would be making it as easy as possible for as many people of the town to be able to watch them play against Widnes in Halifax

It is after all a Halifax council facility , for the benefit of the people of Halifax , the people charged with running it should remember who they actually work for

I think the correct decision was made. We all know about the few who turn up to games with the sole aim of getting hammered

Don't sell beer then

0.5/10

grow up tommy

Says you on a boring wind-up trip.

When you can make a valid point as to why it's 'the correct decision' then you can come back and play.

So far we're had "people turn up intent on drinking" as a H & S reason thus meaning all spectator sport will cease to exist as of tomorrow if that was a risk factor.

What and pay £10+ for the privilege?



Again it's not as if this sort of thing has never been done before so why are council acting like it's some idea off mars that is to risky? This sort of thing happens at least twice a year!

Annoying as seem's Fax & Siddal worked really hard to persuade the council to put the 'double header' together so a cracking day of Rugby League can be had rather than likely two big scores on amateur sides in front of spurse crowds and the council has screwed them right over by making some RIDICULUOS KO times... 11:30 AM!!! This isn't under 12's you know.

Clearly being narrow-minded and want two full rent payments and two full steward payments!

How hard would it be to shut the bars for an hour ? That way those , intent on getting hammered , would decide what meant most to them , watching or drinking

This is the problem with council jobsworths , they are really good at finding potential problems , but totally useless at solving them

This here bloke making this decision isn't just jobsworth, he's physically incapable of doing his job. Everything needs a risk assessment when applying for something to be done/built but intelligent people and Health & Safety advisors etc who are on top of their game will meet with various organisations and authorities and map out how to do these things properly so either nothing happens or you know exactly what to do should it happen.

This person, as you say, is either not good at solving them, can’t do his job or is lazy and doesn’t want to do a proper job then pick up a wage packet he's not earned with 1,000s of people you’re supposed to be representing and ‘helping’ dislike you. Classless. Clueless.