your right, i hold my hands up i was wrong
the rule i was getting mistaken with was...
"it is permissible for a tackler to bring a player in possession of the ball to the ground by pulling him over the outstretched leg provided he is holding the player with both arms before there is any contact with the leg"

penalty try for what ??, think the only was only 3 possible out comes,

1 , try

2 , knock on, unsafe carrie

3 , held up short, play of the ball,



were do u get penalty try from ?????????

I don't know about "shocking discipline" Haighy, after the weekend's programme of games, we'll probably be still top of the fairplay league.

Have you watched the game over? We gave away a shocking amount of 'stupid' penalties, even after the ref penalised us for them more than once, we still did them!

I was stood next to you mate, remember ?
The only reason a large percentage of our penalties are "stupid" is 'cos we're not winning the floor, simple.

Apparently the Batley player was leading with his feet on the line. I thought he was just trying to get there as fast as possible myself but anyway it was given and thats a positive.