I regularly read a whole host of bull on here but you are taking it to a whole new level.

I cannot be bothered going through all of your post as anyone who spends as much time as you making the posts so neat and tidy is a complete pedant.

The two issues above i will comment on though.

The issue of where the Israelis can live is very simple but obviously not for you. Mugwump pointed out that if the Isrealis want to live ousid eof the 1967 boundaries then they can BUT it should not be as part of the state of Isreal. It is the state of Isreal expanding out of the 1967 boundaries which is the ILLEGAL bit.

As for extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence my 8 year old daughter looked at the maps and guessed that the amount of land which had changed from Green to white was 75%. Amazing that an 8 year old can interperate evidence better than you.

You are so so sad and as for trying to pin the anti semite card that is just the last refuge of someone who has lost the arguement.

Your stupidity and pedantry makes me think you are just a WUM rather than someone it is possible to have any rational discussion with. You are not worth replying to on anything else.

Is there a reason you struggle to differentiate Israeli with Jew? Do you think all Jews are Israeli or all Israelis Jews? Is it just Israelis and Jews you struggle with? Do you think all black people are African? All Muslims Arab?

Can you tell me why, when I asked how can a democracy ban living under Jewish rule (Ill help you out here, cos you seem like you need help, maybe it was all that fighting you did when you were young, The answer is they can’t) and how can it be inherently illegal under the UN for a Jew to live in a certain place did you answer with a misplaced rant about the state of Israel? Did you think that Israel and Judaism were interchangeable? Do you have a learning difficulty with basic comprehension or is English not your first language? Are you just an idiot?

And as you have involved your 8 year old daughter, it might be an idea to explain to her that Jews and Israelis aren’t the same thing, not all Jews are Israeli and not all Israelis are Jews, its sad enough your genes have been dumped back in the gene pool, you don’t actively have to teach her to be an idiot as well, she already, clearly, hasnt been given a head start, dont make it worse.

At best you are being disingenuous and / or clouding the issue.
Scattered liberally across the West bank are Israeli settlements, whether they are occupied by Jews is not the point, the point is that they are Israeli settlements/invaders.
Why do I say these settlements are Israeli?... Because they are occupied by Israelis from Israel, living in houses built with Israeli government money, protected by the Israeli Army, in many cases have a ginormous wall around them built by the Israeli state ... and the occupants are not subject to the same "border" checks (by the Israeli Army) that Palestinians are subjected to when they wish to visit Jerusalem (why are they not subject to the same checks? ... because they have Israeli ID).
Most of the UN voted for them not to be there, the dissenting vetoes were from the US, a couple of islands wanting to ingratiate themselves with the US ... and the other was, er, Israel.

They are Israelis invading Palestine.

And you and Hamas believe shooting rockets into Israel will prevent this?

What you are doing here clouding the issue, though i accept that is because previous people have been disingenuous as the converstation moved on. The post was in response to a specific post which showed Jewish settlements and equated them with Israel.
But we werent talking about the settlements in the west bank, specifically this
Which as you can see moves from Jewish to Israeli as if they were the same thing. Thats the point I was making, this map is useless because it treats two different things as if they were the same. As you are doing here (though as i say, that is only obvious if you trace the conversation back) it was a response to specific claims

Its a fair old assumption to argue there was no other reason any other nation voted the way they did. It isnt an argument backed by evidence but assisted by bias to think everyone else voted on conscience whilst they voted politically.
No they are Israelis invading what was Egypt.

He is another simplified explanation of the changing 'borders' of Israel Palestine:

[url=http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/interactive/2011/sep/14/map-israel-palestinian-territoriesChanging map of Israel and the Palestinian territories[/url

And in reference to your observation regarding the "Jewish land" and "Israel Land", this terminology is entirely correct as the first 2 maps refer to pre-1948 borders when the areas under the proposed UN partition were referred to as "Jewish State" and "Arab State".



The second 2 maps provided by Cod'ead refer to the land and borders after the creation of the state of Israel. In actual fact, the key error in the maps is act of referring to 'Palestine' which technically has never existed as a State or Country, it has only existed as a Provinces within the borders of Jordan and Egypt and before that a protectorate under the British Mandate Trans-Jordan and Palestine (the Golan heights are technically Syrian land)

With relation to the interchange of Jewish and Israeli. The State of Israel was established and recognised by the UN to provide a 'home' for 'the Jewish people'. It was never established as a 'Jewish State' and there has never been a restriction on non Jews living in Israel (hold fire on the post 1948 and 1967 refugees). That said, in order to emigrate to Israel and become an Israeli one must be a practising Jew and (or?) of Jewish decent (principally the offspring of a Jewish mother). More recently, Israel has been seeking to be recognised as the "Jewish State of Israel" and frequently refers to itself as such. One of a number of provisions that the Israeli government wishes to introduce is a requirement for all Israeli passport holders and citizens to swear allegiance to "The Jewish State of Israel". Clearly, and arguably understandably, the "1948 Arabs" have issue with swearing allegiance to a Jewish State (there are a number of significant other issues regarding citizenship for 1948 Arabs including requirement to conduct National Service etc but there are too many to discuss here).

Hope that helps

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article ... orrow.html

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article ... orrow.html

No, at least not directly.
What I am saying is that, if I were a Palestinian in Gaza, where Israel has largely destroyed the local economy, killed thousands, and is limiting imports of basic essentials such as medical supplies and food, and I can see my fellows in the West Bank being more and more displaced by Israel as "settlements" push further and further Eastwards, I'd be tempted to hit back.
What does Israel expect? That Gazans will shrug and go along with whatever they say?

Lest we forget the 400 palestinian children shot dead by IDF snipers . All shot through the head. www.youtube.com/verify_age?next_ ... 3f1CdDU5Ck www.guardian.co.uk/world/2005/ju ... lestinians www.duncanmcfarlane.org/Israel-P ... errorists/ LOve the storty aboyt the Israeli officer who shoots a 12 year old girl twice. When she is lying on the floor he then approaches her and fires the rest of his clip into her body on the ground. Some of his soldiers are so appalled they report him to their superiors. He is acquitted of murder, sentenced to 45 days and stripped of his command in the unit because he has lost the confidence of his men. Palestinian lives are very cheap. Still that is what happens when the untermensch become the master race and find their own untermensch

Lest we forget the 400 palestinian children shot dead by IDF snipers . All shot through the head. www.youtube.com/verify_age?next_ ... 3f1CdDU5Ck www.guardian.co.uk/world/2005/ju ... lestinians www.duncanmcfarlane.org/Israel-P ... errorists/ LOve the storty aboyt the Israeli officer who shoots a 12 year old girl twice. When she is lying on the floor he then approaches her and fires the rest of his clip into her body on the ground. Some of his soldiers are so appalled they report him to their superiors. He is acquitted of murder, sentenced to 45 days and stripped of his command in the unit because he has lost the confidence of his men. Palestinian lives are very cheap. Still that is what happens when the untermensch become the master race and find their own untermensch

I continue to equate them with Israel because they are Israeli-occupied settlements, Israeli state-financed and Israeli state-protected.
It sems as though you are making out that they are merely Jewish people who happen to live in Palestine, I am saying this is not the case, they may well be Jewish (in fact almost certainly are Jewish) but that is not the point, it is Israeli-state-sponsored invasion.

[url=http://www.hrw.org/news/2012/10/03/gaza-arbitrary-arrests-torture-unfair-trialslovely people[/url ,just the sort of neighbours we would all want to have, eh?

Yes much better to shoot them like the israelis do.

My mind must be playing tricks on me, but according to most news reports rockets came from Gaza FIRST and continue to be fired into populated areas of Israel, you cannot blame Israel for having better technology, unless of course you feel a dead Jewish kid is not as important than a dead Arab kid. I feel for the innocent Palastinians, but they voted these nut jobs in KNOWING what they would do. If my neighbour kept throwing stones into my garden when my grandkids were in it, I would sooner or later jump over the fence and knock the crap out of him.

Nope, that would be impossible, they predated the creation of Israel.

Israel was first formed in 11th century BC not 1948 if you take history as written.

Those guys are even worse! I hate long ago peoples with their ancient ways.

Though without getting into that debate i did mean prior to the modern state of Israel

I know, just practicing my pedantry, it seems to flourish on here.

I think [iall[/i kids lives are important, unlike quite a few on here.
I'm also in Hedon today so I might try lobbing a few stones over your fence, just to see if your 'all mouth and no trousers'.

Give over, they are new houses, for recently-moved families, built using Israeli government cash.

There is to be a ceasfire at 7pm tonight. Hopefully it'll last and get the two sides together and sort something out.

You forgot the bit about the recently bulldozed Palestinian houses to create the space.

Another helpful map:



Full size link [url=http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/d8/Westbankjan06.jpgHERE[/url

A ' Victory '

I honestly have no idea what you're going on about.


Only one of us is living in a fantasy land of our own creation, and only one of us has even [imentioned[/i equality of suffering. I'll give you a clue - it isn't me.

And your analogy with events in North and South America sucks. The events aren't even remotely comparable for a whole variety of reasons and even making the attempt indicates you basic lack of comprehension.


Once again you miss the point by a country mile. Who even mentioned a commitment to 'nuclear safety'? Or even that there were no circumstances under which nukes would be used? My point was that the geographical proximity of Gaza makes it just as unlikely a target for a nuclear strike as the West Bank.

Anyway - I guess we can all hope that the current ceasefire last longer than most. Although with both sides wittering on about 'victory' I can't say I'm optimistic.

Why?
In particular, North America in what is now the USA.
Indigeneous population moved aside to make way for settlers ... and when they fight back they are met with massively violent retribution.

Sounds similar to me.