Home Page · Site Forum · rugbyleagueontv.co.uk - RL TV Listings & RL Audio Match Commentary · DVD Swaps · Facebook Page · Twitter Tuesday, February 25, 2020
2016 First Team
2016 Season Fixtures
2016 Results/Reports
2016 Stats Centre
Wigan RL History Pages
Historical Results at a Glance
Club Honours & Records
Wigan RL - Big Match Database
You Tube Video Play List
Wigan RL A to Z Player List
Wigan RL Heritage Numbers
Wigan RL Timeline
Wigan RL "Top" Timeline
Wigan v Saints - Derby Archive
Challenge Cup Record
League Cup Record
Lancashire Cup Record
All Time Head to Head Records
All Time Player Records
Central Park
The DW Stadium
Co-Operative Stadium, Orrell
Super League Only Stats
All Time SL Table
Classic Matches
Record Victory
8 in a Row!
Coaching Register
Average Attendances
Great Britain Register
Home Nation Register
Wigan - Miscellany
Playing Kit Archive
Two Teams in Wigan!
Wigan Highfield
Springfield Borough
Match Report: St Helens 10 Wigan 18
Posted by Bilko on April 02 2010 - 17:01

Click: Last Derby - Click: Last Match - Click: Next Match - Click: Next Derby

St Helens v Wigan Warriors - Engage Super League XV Round 9.
Good Friday 2nd April 2010. Kick Off 3:00pm at Knowsley Road.

Image: Front page of League Weekly newspaper following the derby.

Match Report

Was a very emotional 80 minutes for me today after my Grandfather passed away just yesterday at the age of 91. He was a big Wigan follower and would often reminisce about travelling to Leeds in knee deep snow and of the great post war era when the likes of Tommy Bradshaw, Ken Gee and Johnny Lawrenson (who also passed away this week) played in Cherry & White. It was him taking me to Central Park as a child that got me into following Wigan RL, so on a personal note today's victory was extra special. Really proud of the effort from our boys today.

So why did we win? Quite simple, we only made 5 handling errors all game. Considering the rainy conditions that was a great effort!

Saints in comparison made 15 handling errors. Part due to good Wigan defence and part due to lack of composure. To me, St Helens today looked like this current Wigan side before Michael Maguire started coaching them. They looked desperate, lacking in leadership, struggling for pace and if Eastmond didn't cause problems, no one did.

Having said that I don't think Wigan had the best of days with their kicking game, but we just did enough when it mattered.

Defensively we were outstanding. Saints fans said their pack would run over us but it wasn't really the case. Both sides put in some massive hits.

At the end of the day we would have lost that game last year. Under immense pressure on our line, we would have cracked easily but today it took a sin binning to allow Saints to get back into the game. 13 v 13 we did not concede a point.

Story of the match - Well, Wigan started well with a good touching finding clearance kick from Sam Tomkins in the 1st minute. I was hoping this would be a sign of things to come but Saints cottoned on to that and made sure their wingers got back to defend kicks.

First Wigan opportunity came in the 5th minute after Francis Meli was said to have knocked on in his own half. A penalty then followed after Jon Wilkin was accused of ball stealing and Wigan took the two with a penalty from Richards.

On the back of that, Saints had a good spell of territory with the help of three  penalties from referee Ben Thaler. Keiron Cunningham was held up on the line, flung the ball back and Sam Tomkins reacted first to claim possession.

Saints got straight back on the attack after a poor last tackle kick from Leuluai. It gave them a turnover on half way but on the last Chris Dean was denied a try with good tackling from Darrell Goulding.

14 minutes - Saints knock on half way, and Wigan almost take advantage. Richards charged down the right wing and tried to take three men over the line with him, but he just got held short. Good last tackle kick from Sam Tomkins caused problems but O'Loughlin couldn't take a bouncing ball which would have seen him go under the sticks. Next attack another good kick from Tomkins just beat everyone in the in goal.

Soon after it was Saints turn to cause problems with a kick. Kyle Eastmond put the bomb up, it held in the wind, and went straight into the arms of Dean but four Wigan defenders scrambled back to stop him.

A high tackle from O'Loughlin on Leon Pryce got Saints on the attack again, but Wigan continued to hold firm. This despite a good kick from Eastmond forcing a drop out. Saints ended up being penalised for offside.

Leuluai though again handed the initiative back to Saints with a forward pass.  I can recall bemoaning continuous poor play from Leuluai in one of last year's visits to Knowsley Road and again, for me, he was disappointing today. You need tactical leadership in the halves and I'm not sure Leuluai provides this.

Wigan then lost George Carmont to a knee injury on 25 minutes. The contest looked to be heading to half time in stalemate, with the teams having cancelled each other out with hardly any clean  breaks being achieved. It needed a smart bit of play to turn the tide and it came in the 28th minute.

Eamon O'Carroll had knocked on 20 metres from his own line, under a tackle from James Graham. The whole ground expected another Saints attack at Wigan's line but it ended up the other way round. Wigan pushed at the scrum and ended up on the break away with Sean O'Loughlin. Defence scrambled back but only to concede a penalty. Tapping it, a scrappy pass towards the right wing went to ground but ricocheted towards the try line and Goulding pounced to score. Video Ref Phil Bentham awarded it and a huge touchline conversion from Richards make it 8-0. Goulding is technically a back up player but that's his 8th try in 6 matches this season.

Wigan were now on the front foot and a knock on by Maurie Fa'asavalu got them attacking the line. Jon Wilkin conceded a high tackle penalty to help our cause, as did a back to one in the left corner, before a second penalty conceded by Wilkin, saw Wigan punish.

Feka Paleaaesina returned to the first team today (replacing injured Andy Coley) after missing the last three matches. He did well when he came on and running from a tap penalty 5 metres out, he ran over Wilkin, Fa'asavalu and Roby to score. Richards conversion made it 14-0 and that's how it remained until half time.

The start of the second half was also crucial to this victory. We all knew Saints would come out stronger but Wigan took a valuable four minutes off the clock by winning the ball from the kick off. It hung in the wind and Fielden batted it back to Feka. Saints eventually conceded a penalty right under the sticks to give Pat an easy two points at 16-0.

After that it was pretty much all Saints attack but Wigan's defence was holding up very firm. In the 46th minute referee Thaler sin binned Amos Roberts for a silly interference right under the posts. Stupid play!

During his ten minute absence Saints scored twice. Moments after his yellow card, James Roby was held up under great defence by Richards. That decision had gone to the video referee and Wigan were caught cold after the NO TRY had been flashed on the screen. Quick play the ball saw Eastmond kick to the right wing and Gardner had a walk in try with no defender near him. Conversion off the touchline made it 16-6.

Memories of the trip to Bradford last month immediately flooded to my head, and probably the players as well, but in fairness we didn't mentally collapse. Tony Puletua being well held up by Fielden and Prescott on 53 minutes highlighted that.

However, Puletua would score the next time he drove at the line with a close range charge over, just 11 seconds before Roberts was due to return from the bin. Eastmond though missed a far easier conversion that his first goal and then meant Wigan still had a 16-10 lead.

I've no doubt at this point Wigan fans feared the worst and Saints fans feared another smug Easter was coming their way, but despite plenty of effort Wigan hung on under 15 minutes of pressure. Saints looked to be in with a chance of levelling the scores on the hour but Dean's pass to send Francis Meli in the left corner was rightly called forward.

Mick Potter's side continued to press but crucially they could not force any repeat sets. Their last tackle options were not harming Wigan. But they got a huge chance on 67 minutes when Roberts was penalised for obstruction on Wilkin ten metres from his own line. However, Leon Pryce ended up knocking on.

Although the clock was ticking into the final ten minutes, you felt Wigan needed a drop goal at least, to seal the win. They needed a special play to get out of their own territory and it came from Sam Tomkins in the 73rd minute. He had actually broken the line moments earlier but had to kick on the last, this time he was on the second tackle and St Helens, desperately hanging on, conceded a penalty. Richards went for goal despite the tough angle and kicked to make it 18-10 with 6 minutes to go.

Saints never looked like scoring twice and Wigan saw out the final moments to claim their first win at Knowsley Road since September 5th 2003. Well done lads!

Reaction to the Action

Coach Michael Maguire: "I definitely felt (the derby day) passion. The people around me were all getting stuck into me. It was rather good fun actually. It was one of the most amazing atmospheres from a game I've experienced. Since I landed, when I walked into my first pub, everybody told me if I didn't win anything but we beat St Helens, they'd be happy with me. It was quite an unusual welcome but I can understand it because there's a lot of passion between the two teams.  Halfway through the week, we didn't have half a team in training. I didn't know what sort of team I would have until this morning. I'm very proud of them. They showed great character. There were a few nerves when we were down to 12 men but it was an outstanding effort from the boys to hang in."

Saints coach Mick Potter: "We had our chances but we're a little disappointed with our execution. We got over the line a few times and went close on others and it cost us. It was back to winter rugby and we got bogged down a bit in the first half. It was difficult to get any roll-on. We couldn't do what we had practised. We had to scramble in the second half and we weren't good enough to capitalise on the opportunities we created."

Team Sheets

-St HelensPositionWigan-
6Leon PryceFull BackAmos Roberts2
2Ade GardnerWingerDarrell Goulding24
3Matt GidleyCentreMartin Gleeson3
19Chris DeanCentreGeorge Carmont4
5Francis MeliWingerPat Richards5
12Jon WilkinStand OffSam Tomkins6
7Kyle EastmondScrum HalfThomas Leuluai7
10James GrahamPropStuart Fielden8
9Keiron CunninghamHookerMike McIlorum15
11Tony PuletuaPropPaul Prescott14
17Paul Clough2nd RowPhil Bailey16
13Chris Flannery2nd RowJoel Tomkins12
16Scott MooreL.ForwardSean O'Loughlin13
14James RobySubstituteIafeta Paleaaesina17
15Bryn HargreavesSubstitutePaul Deacon19
22Andrew DixonSubstituteEamon O'Carroll21
23Maurie Fa'asavaluSubstituteLee Mossop23
-Mick PotterCoachMichael Maguire-

Score Sheet

St Helens 10---Wigan Warriors 18
Tries (2):
Ade Gardner
Tony Puletua
---Tries (2):
Darrell Goulding
Iafeta Paleaaesina
Kyle Eastmond 1/2
Pat Richards 5/5

Scoring and Incident Pattern

04mins:46St Helens 00Wigan 02Penalty Goal: Pat Richards (1/1)
28mins:21St Helens 00Wigan 06Try: Darrell Goulding (Video Ref)
-St Helens 00Wigan 08Conversion: Pat Richards (2/2)
33mins:07St Helens 00Wigan 12Try: Iafeta Paleaaesina (Video Ref)
-St Helens 00Wigan 14Conversion: Pat Richards (3/3)
Half TimeSt Helens 00 Wigan Warriors 14
42mins:07St Helens 00Wigan 16Penalty Goal: Pat Richards (4/4)
45mins:09Wigan Sin BinAmos Roberts (Delaying Restart)
46mins:14St H Video Ref No TryJames Roby (Held Up)
46mins:20St Helens 04Wigan 16Try: Ade Gardner
-St Helens 06Wigan 16Conversion: Kyle Eastmond (1/1)
54mins:58St Helens 10Wigan 16Try: Tony Puletua
-St Helens 10Wigan 16K.Eastmond Missed Conversion (1/2)
72mins:17St Helens 10Wigan 18Penalty Goal: Pat Richards (5/5)
Full TimeSt Helens 10 Wigan Warriors 18

Video Highlights

Top 5 Wigan Players as voted on our Message Board

Man of the Match: Lee Mossop
2nd: Sean O'Loughlin 3rd: Joel Tomkins 4th: Martin Gleeson 5th: Sam Tomkins


Ben Thaler


-St HelensWigan
Penalties Conceded1414
Handling Errors155
Missed Tackles2219
Ball Carries208198
Metres Made1313m1129m
Clean Breaks12
Drop Outs Forced21

Video Referee

Phil Bentham

Match Attendance

17,500 (Capacity)



Wet and Windy

League Table at Conclusion of Super League 15 Round 9

1Wigan Warriors9801296114+182W416
2Warrington Wolves9702281114+167W214
3Huddersfield Giants9603234108+126W112
4St Helens9603237166+71L112
5Hull FC9603212157+55W112
6Wakefield Wildcats9603192184+8W112
7Bradford Bulls9414141187-46U29
8Hull Kingston Rovers9405147193-46L28
9Leeds Rhinos9315200159+49U17
10Castleford Tigers9306174232-58L16
12Salford City Reds9207111229-118L14
13Catalans Dragons9207104248-144L14

Round 9 Results - (Maundy Thursday/Good Friday)

Thu 1 AprCrusaders v Harlequins - Match Postponed-
Thu 1 AprLeeds Rhinos 20 Bradford Bulls 2017,244
Fri 2 AprHull Kingston Rovers 14 Hull FC 1810,089
Fri 2 AprSt Helens 10 Wigan Warriors 1817,500
Fri 2 AprWarrington Wolves 32 Salford City Reds 211,467
Fri 2 AprHuddersfield Giants 48 Catalans Dragons 65,926
Fri 2 AprWakefield Wildcats 19 Castleford Tigers 68,337

No Comments have been Posted.
Post Comment
Please Login to Post a Comment.
Rating is available to Members only.

Please login or register to vote.

No Ratings have been Posted.
Donate to Website

If you appreciate the efforts made on this site and would like to see them continue, donations are welcome to cover the increased running costs of this website. Cheers.

View a Previous Season.....

A to Z Player List


Remember Me

Lost Password?

Copyright - Cherryandwhite.co.uk 2002-2014
Whilst every effort is made to ensure that news stories are correct, we cannot be held responsible for errors. Some articles and pictures on this website have been recovered from various sources for archive purposes. If any material on this website is subject to copyright or incorrect in any way please contact us webmaster@cherryandwhite.co.uk so we can remove it or negotiate copyright permission.
RLFANS.COM, the owners of this website, the RLSA (Rugby League Supporters Association) or the 100% League Network are not responsible for the content of its sub-sites, please email the author of this sub-site if you feel you find an article offensive or of a choice nature that you disagree with.

Email RLFANS.COM's owners admins@rlfans.com if further assistance is required.

©1999-2014 RLFANS.COM