Home Page · Site Forum · rugbyleagueontv.co.uk - RL TV Listings & RL Audio Match Commentary · DVD Swaps · Facebook Page · Twitter Tuesday, January 21, 2020
2016 First Team
2016 Season Fixtures
2016 Results/Reports
2016 Stats Centre
Wigan RL History Pages
Historical Results at a Glance
Club Honours & Records
Wigan RL - Big Match Database
You Tube Video Play List
Wigan RL A to Z Player List
Wigan RL Heritage Numbers
Wigan RL Timeline
Wigan RL "Top" Timeline
Wigan v Saints - Derby Archive
Challenge Cup Record
League Cup Record
Lancashire Cup Record
All Time Head to Head Records
All Time Player Records
Central Park
The DW Stadium
Co-Operative Stadium, Orrell
Super League Only Stats
All Time SL Table
Classic Matches
Record Victory
8 in a Row!
Coaching Register
Average Attendances
Great Britain Register
Home Nation Register
Wigan - Miscellany
Playing Kit Archive
Two Teams in Wigan!
Wigan Highfield
Springfield Borough
Match Report: Wigan 18 Castleford 12
Posted by Bilko on September 20 2009 - 20:20

Click: Last Match - Click: Next Match

Wigan Warriors v Castleford Tigers - Engage SL 14 Elimination Play Off
Sunday 20th September 2009. Kick Off 7:00pm at DW Stadium.

Well this match followed the pattern of the previous play off games this weekend. Very flat game with a low crowd, but Wigan are through and that's all that matters. A game with a total of 32 handling errors (16 each) was never going to be pretty and Wigan will need to improve on that next week.

For me this match saw Wigan start badly and finish badly but they got enough points in the middle part of the game to see them home. Bit like the Hull FC game earlier in the month, the bench really changed things and won us the game.

Both sides though started poorly, although Wigan could have taken the lead in the third minute with Harrison Hansen held up over the line. Two minutes later we looked to have opened them up out wide but Sean O'Loughlin put in a terrible kick that was easily snaffled up by James Evans.

Two penalties, one for an high tackle by Andy Coley and the other for not standing square, saw Richard Owen go within a bugs dick of scoring on 9 minutes but George Carmont somehow scrambled back. Wigan survived after Michael Shenton threw a pass into touch.

On 12 minutes Wigan looked to be in good attacking position after receiving their first penalty for a flop but Andy Coley soon knocked on. He had a poor night Coley, making four or five errors that I can remember.

Next chance came on 16 minutes. Sean O'Loughlin sent a bullet pass out wide to Pat Richards who decided to kick and chase, but his kick was far too deep. Not really what was needed on tackle 4. Wigan really need to learn how to build pressure.

Soon after that Wigan conceded their fourth penalty of the game after a high shot from Mike McIlorum, who started at hooker tonight ahead of Riddell. That got Castleford attacking Wigan's line and again Richard Owen was close to going over but McIlorum kept him out. A nice dink from Sherwin forced George Carmont into being trapped in goal but the drop out ended up with a knock on.

Bang on 20 minutes coach Brian Noble interchanged Paul Prescott, Mike McIlorum and Andy Coley for Stuart Fielden, Mark Riddell and Feka Paleaaesina. Instantly Wigan looked far more sharper. Five drives went in before a last tackle bomb to the left corner from Thomas Leuluai was batted back by Pat Richards for Harrison Hansen to touch down. Bit of deliberation by video ref Phil Bentham but the try was given. So just 80 seconds after the triple substitutions, Wigan had taken the lead. Richards hit a good conversion as well to make it 6-0.

The trio had definitely made an impact but a big error came on 27 minutes with Riddell kicking out on the full from half way. That error went unpunished and so did an incorrect play the ball from Fielden a minute later, even though Cas forced a drop out. A great drop out as well from Pat who kicked it 80 metres, just like last week at Huddersfield.

Wigan would increased their lead on 32 minutes after getting good territory following a high tackle penalty against Liam Higgins. It was a carbon copy of the first try. On the last Leuluai bomb to the left wing and Richards collected and offloaded for the try. This time George Carmont was the benefactor and the conversion made it 12-0. These kicks would prove vital at the back end of the game.

That was it until half time although perhaps Ryan McGoldrick should have been penalised for a high shot on Cameron Phelps which also saw him look to be choking him whilst on the ground? I think he deserved sin binning for his embarrassing pony tail but no penalty given by the ref.

Wigan's first half set completion had been just 45%, compared to 67% for Cas - so to be 12-0 up was pretty pleasing. You did feel first try of the second half would be enough to win and I suppose it did turn out that way. The first score came in the form of a penalty goal kicked by Richards after a grapple tackle by James Evans on Sam Tomkins.

I get the feeling though Wigan don't know how to play when leading. They know how to chase games down but they never keep things calm and simply. After that penalty they knocked on giving Cas an immediate chance to reply but luckily they wasted that chance with a kick from prop Mitchell Sargeant for some reason.

Wigan went on the chase up the other end with good terriotry after a high tackle on the last by McGoldrick on Phelps again. It was a bit wide to take the two so Wigan tapped but immediately knocked on by Coley.

A third try of the game would come though on 52 minutes after a kick to the left wing by O'Loughlin for Richards to chase forced a drop out. From that Sam Tomkins and Phelps combined to send Amos Roberts racing over in the right corner. Richards couldn't convert off the touchline  but at 18-0 the game looked secure.

Like I said though Wigan just didn't play clever in the last 25 minutes. Sam Tomkins was deemed to have knocked on two metres from his own line after a kick from Brent Sherwin. Sam shook his head after the replay on the screen but Ian Smith gave Cas the ball. We defended five good attempts at the line but on the last O'Loughlin but in a stupid push whilst marking at the play the ball. So another set to defend. First shot of the line saw Joe Westerman held up. Wigan got them on the last again and a dink to the corner trapped Roberts one metre out in the corner.

Now Wigan had seen out 12 tackles on the line but two minutes later they would finally break out resilience. After a further six tackles had been defended, Cameron Phelps knocked on a bomb from Sherwin under his own posts. The pressure became too much although try scorer Craig Huby was able to take advantage of some poor defence from Phelps and Joel Tomkins. Easy conversion from Westerman made it 18-6 with 19 minutes to go.

Now all Wigan needed to do to halt any chance of a comeback was to kick a drop goal. In the Challenge Cup Semi Wigan had full momentum having thought back from 32-8 to 32-26 but Lee Briers knew what to do. First chance he got he nailed a drop goal and all that momentum was finished in an instant. We didn't do that tonight though.

We didn't complete sets well either with another knock on from Coley gifted Cas possession 30 metres out. Luckily they knocked on, then they gave Wigan a penalty after Higgins hit Paul Prescott with a high tackle. So Wigan had the ball in their half and just needed to drive, drive, drive, drive, drive for the posts and slot one over to end the contest. But despite being in a perfect position after three tackles, Wigan looked to go out wide and Sam Tomkins knocked on a pass from Riddell.

The next chance to kick a drop goal came after another high tackle penalty, this time against ex Wigan player Stuart Jones, with Phelps was on the receiving end again. Would they kick the one point this time? Well they attempted but Cas defended well in fairness. They trapped Sam Tomkins before Phelps' effort went way wide. For me though earlier in the set their were too many unnecessary passes out wide. Just keep it simple and drive at the posts! It was frustrating the hell out of me!

A third chance came on 71 minutes but again they went passing out wide and O'Loughlin threw forward to Pat Richards. We didn't need 4 points, one would have done!

My frustration grew when Cas went on the attack again. An interference penalty was given under the posts but James Evans knocked on out wide. Driving out Wigan just needed to complete the set but Phelps knocked on twenty from his own line. It was suicidal rugby and they made that error pay with Westerman being sent over by Owen. He also converted to make it 18-12.

For me the Tigers were never good enough to win this game but Wigan's poor inability to kill this game off was looking to cost them dearly. We really missed an experience head to just keep things calm and composed.

When Wigan restarted their was 3 and half minutes left for Cas to force extra time. On the last tackle they tried to run it down the left but Wigan's defence was too good. Michael Shenton put a bomb in the air, Phelps missed it (but looked to have been taken out in the air to me), which allowed Shenton to regather, he kicked again out towards the right wing but with two players chasing with no defenders to beat, the ball thankfully skipped out into touch.

Two minutes to go from the scrum and finally a bit of composure from Wigan. Five drives and  with them not being in drop goal range Sam Tomkins put in an excellent kick which trapped Cas close to their own line. A minute was left now and they had to force the pass. On the last Sherwin for some reason didn't kick, instead putting in a poor pass that Leuluai easily gobbled up. Ten seconds to go Wigan get hold of it, hooter went and thank **** for that!

Not a clever last twenty for me. One regular encouraged me to criticised the ref in this report but I look at our own poor play. Ok the luck did go the way of the opposition in the last twenty but we show have killed them off ourselves with a simple drop goal. The inexperience showed. No one stood up and took control. Can't expect Sam Tomkins to do it at his age. Thomas Leuluai perhaps needs to hold his hand up. He is the experience half back after all.

Noble summed it up with his comments. "Our issue is with the ball" and thats it to a tee. We can defend, we just need to be a bit more clever in attack.

Anyway it should be a cracking trip to Hull KR next Saturday - bring it on!

Reaction to the Action

Brian Noble: "I always thought we were the better team. I thought we dominated the game for 60 or 65 minutes and came up with couple of errors that let Castleford back in the game. I thought we defended really well, it was a couple of individual errors that let Castleford back in. Our issue is with the ball, we need to look after the ball a bit better but there were some really good efforts tonight. I thought Cameron Phelps was magnificent and Pat Richards was very good."

Click Here for Cameron Phelps & Pat Richards Post Match Interviews with Sky Sports.

Castleford coach Terry Matterson: "The players are gutted in there because it is a real missed opportunity. We felt we had a real chance of going further. It was our worst attacking performance of the season, our skills were really poor. Defensively I thought we were outstanding - they scored two tries off kicks - but, if you don't respect possession in these games, it's very difficult. But you've got to give credit to Wigan, they defended well."

Team Sheets

21Cameron PhelpsFull BackRichard Owen1
2Amos RobertsWingerKirk Dixon2
22Martin GleesonCentreMichael Shenton3
4George CarmontCentreJames Evans4
5Pat RichardsWingerMichael Wainwright5
25Sam TomkinsStand OffRyan McGoldrick23
7Thomas LeuluaiScrum HalfBrent Sherwin7
15Andy ColeyPropMitchell Sargeant8
17Mike McIlorumHookerRangi Chase9
19Paul PrescottPropCraig Huby10
14Joel Tomkins2nd RowBrett Ferres11
16Harrison Hansen2nd RowRyan Clayton12
13Sean O'LoughlinL.ForwardStuart Jones14
8Stuart FieldenSubstituteJoe Westerman13
9Mark RiddellSubstituteLiam Higgins15
10Iafeta PaleaaesinaSubstituteChris Feather16
26Mark FlanaganSubstituteKirk Netherton19

Brian Noble


Terry Matterson


Score Sheet

Wigan Warriors 18---Castleford tigers 12
Tries (3):
Harrison Hansen
George Carmont
Amos Roberts
---Tries (2):
Craig Huby
Joe Westerman
Pat Richards 3/4
Joe Westerman 2/2

Scoring and Incident Pattern

21mins:48Wigan 04Castleford 00Try: Harrison Hansen (Video Ref)
-Wigan 06Castleford 00Conversion: Pat Richards (1/1)
31mins:07Wigan 10Castleford 00Try: George Carmont
-Wigan 12Castleford 00Conversion: Pat Richards (2/2)
Half TimeWigan Warriors 12 Castleford Tigers 00
42mins:58Wigan 14Castleford 00Penalty Goal: Pat Richards (3/3)
51mins:32Wigan 18Castleford 00Try: Amos Roberts
-Wigan 18Castleford 00P.Richards Missed Conversion (3/4)
60mins:50Wigan 18Castleford 04Try: Craig Huby
-Wigan 18Castleford 06Conversion: Joe Westerman (1/1)
75mins:10Wigan 18Castleford 10Try: Joe Westerman
-Wigan 18Castleford 12Conversion: Joe Westerman (2/2)
Full TimeWigan Warriors 18 Castleford Tigers 12

Video Highlights


Ian Smith (Oldham)

Penalites Conceded

Wigan 7 Castleford 8

Handling Errors

Wigan 16 Castleford 16

Goal Line Drop Outs Forced

Wigan 1 Castleford 2

Video Referee

Phil Bentham (Warrington)

Match Attendance

8,689 (1,890 Away Supporters)



Dry Night.

No Comments have been Posted.
Post Comment
Please Login to Post a Comment.
Rating is available to Members only.

Please login or register to vote.

No Ratings have been Posted.
Donate to Website

If you appreciate the efforts made on this site and would like to see them continue, donations are welcome to cover the increased running costs of this website. Cheers.

View a Previous Season.....

A to Z Player List


Remember Me

Lost Password?

Copyright - Cherryandwhite.co.uk 2002-2014
Whilst every effort is made to ensure that news stories are correct, we cannot be held responsible for errors. Some articles and pictures on this website have been recovered from various sources for archive purposes. If any material on this website is subject to copyright or incorrect in any way please contact us webmaster@cherryandwhite.co.uk so we can remove it or negotiate copyright permission.
RLFANS.COM, the owners of this website, the RLSA (Rugby League Supporters Association) or the 100% League Network are not responsible for the content of its sub-sites, please email the author of this sub-site if you feel you find an article offensive or of a choice nature that you disagree with.

Email RLFANS.COM's owners admins@rlfans.com if further assistance is required.

©1999-2014 RLFANS.COM