1. Jim Sharrock, 2. Jim Leytham, 3. Bert Jenkins, 4. Lance Todd, 5. Walter Creevey, 6. Johnny Thomas. 7. Fred Gleave

WiganlTries:l

WiganlGoals:l

Two days after the original tie, the replay was witnessed by 14,000 at Central Park. Wigan took the lead with a Jim Leytham try that was converted by himself for 5-0. Leigh responded before half time with a try from T.Johnson that was converted by Molyneux for 5-5. After the break Wigan pushed on and found two tries with Leytham claiming a second before Lance Todd put Wigan into a two score lead, despite failed conversions.

After the match Leigh reported Wigan to the Northern Rugby Union Committee citing rule 12 that Massa Johnston had left the field at one point to change his playing jersey without the permission of the referee. The ruling was that if you leave the field without the referee's permission you can't then later return. Having doing that and thus broken that rule, it was decided a day later to uphold Leigh's protest. The NRU decided that the result of this match would be voided and the tie was to be replayed the following Monday.